Books

Nobody Deserves Anything

Three essays published recently — The Children of the Boomers (Destino), by Estefanía Molina; No Respect (Paidós), by Byung-Chul Han; and Nobody Deserves Anything (Anagrama), by Jahel Queralt — converge, from different perspectives, around shared concerns: the culture of effort, meritocracy — understood either as a promise of social mobility or as an expression of neoliberalism — and the relationship between effort, success, and social recognition.

While Molina focused mainly on the rupture of the generational contract and the difficulty for Spanish youths to turn their effort and work into housing and stability, defending the meritocratic promise as an emancipatory possibility of social democracy, Han sees in the neoliberal competitive logic — understood here as meritocracy — a threat to the respect that individuals have for themselves and for others. For him, failure becomes personal guilt, which gives rise to “losers” unable to recognize themselves in a shared experience and prone to a resentment that can lead to a molecular civil war of the social body.

The essay by Queralt, about which the rest of this review will treat, offers a nuance that perhaps positions it as a counterpoint between Molina and Han. It shares with the South Korean thinker the distrust between success and personal value, but it resists discarding the meritocratic ideal. Like Molina, it recognizes its original egalitarian and emancipatory potential, though it insists on stripping it of the moral value with which the rewards and resulting inequalities are justified.

“The example is revealing insofar as it shows that recognizing an inequality does not mean resigning oneself to it, but identifying the means to correct it when possible“

I must confess approaching Queralt’s essay somewhat biased by the critique it receives in The Objective by Rafael Núñez Florencio, with whom I agree on the necessity of not removing individual effort from the equation of success. That no path can be fully explained apart from the social, familial, and also genetic circumstances that condition it — as Queralt argues in her chapter “Genes of Gold and Silver Spoons” — does not mean that it can be reduced entirely to them. Between two individuals who start from similar conditions, there can be considerable differences in terms of will or discipline that also contribute to explain their respective destinies. Recognizing the weight of what we do not choose should not lead us to ignore what, within those limits, we do with what we have. Yet here is where Queralt introduces an argument that would put to the test those who would see biology as the dominant factor in a trajectory: biology.

“With this blindness, we do a disservice precisely to those who most need to overcome these starting limitations that the author identifies in the social and genetic lotteries“

Even those qualities we tend to consider most distinctly ours — such as constancy or discipline — can depend largely on a genetic lottery over which we have little control. That randomness is what determines whether one can distinguish a musical note from another or become Aphex Twin, and no amount of musical training, however excellent, can grant you the ear of a genius if you were not luckier in the genetic lottery. It is striking, moreover, how naturally the author brings the weight of genetic heredity into her argument, given firsthand the misgivings that the mere mention of biological differences between individuals typically arouse in academic circles. “What is not named cannot be corrected,” the author rightly says, citing as a striking example the case of Messi. What would he have been without the hormonal treatment that allowed him to overcome an initial biological disadvantage? The example is revealing insofar as it shows that recognizing inequality does not mean resigning oneself to it, but identifying the means to correct it when possible.

“With this blindness, we do a disservice precisely to those who most need to overcome these starting limitations that the author identifies in the social and genetic lotteries“

Translating her analysis to the field of education, the essay challenges the traditional left’s stance of explaining differences in performance almost exclusively through students’ social origin. While by no means denying the enormous weight of family and material circumstances in individual trajectories, the author reminds us that these do not exhaust the explanation. The genetic lottery also intervenes. The environment, to borrow an analogy, constitutes the soil in which naturally inherited aptitudes can develop, so that the same natural dispositions may meet very different conditions for flourishing. This could be expressed with the English phrase nature via nurture.

Queralt relies on the theses of Hillel Steiner and Thomas Nagel and on data provided by the Ministry of Education that reflect the gap in school learning that a fifteen-year-old from a “well-off” family in Spain would have compared to one from a poor family. The author proposes addressing this through fair opportunities so that each person can become the best candidate they can be. It is hard not to recognize the nobility of this ideal of justice in which one has believed for years, until teaching experience forces you to confront it with some of its practical applications, which tend more toward equal outcomes than toward equal opportunities. It is also hard not to fall into the trap after years in a profession dominated by pedagogical currents that, in their push to ensure no one is left behind, end up lowering common expectations rather than providing the resources needed for disadvantaged students to reach them. Thus there is a double contradiction: acting as if everyone possessed identical aptitudes, ignoring individual differences — including those of biological origin — while renouncing to compensate for those disadvantages that schooling could indeed intervene upon. With this blindness we do a disservice precisely to those who most need to overcome starting limitations that the author identifies in the social and genetic lotteries.

Yet, a reader will fully share the core distinction of the essay: being the most competent candidate or receiving higher incomes does not grant anyone greater moral worth. Merit can justify a selection without thereby justifying all the inequalities that arise from it. Forgetting this, we might risk moving toward the society described by Han, in which success is confounded with dignity and failure becomes guilt, thereby laying the groundwork for a society of shamelessness filled with “anti-heroes” whose damaged egos are ready to destroy everything, even their own self.

—————————————

Author: Jahel Queralt. Title: Nobody Deserves Anything. Publisher: Anagrama. Where to buy: Todos tus libros.






0/5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *