The beloved and indispensable Diccionario de la lengua española treasures a term that is used only on the homeland, yet it would be wise to import for all nations scourged by extreme polarization: guerracivilismo. “A tendency to split a country into divided or irreconcilable camps, prioritizing ideological clash over social harmony.” We could say then that the first torpedo fired by Pope Leo XIV at the tense Argentine vessel targeted that culture of collective discord that severely conspires against liberal democracy. It was when he urged us to take care with words and public debate, and to foster dialogue “with those who think differently” and not blow up bridges—a duty not only befitting Javier Milei and his “forces from heaven”—they would benefit greatly from sincere self-criticism—but also to the camps of Cristina Kirchner, who in their time rekindled the sleeping herpes of the native rift, zealously wrestled for hegemony, attacked and stigmatized the press and the dissidents—“gorillas” and “antipatria”—and now tear their garments when libertarians heed the advice of Laclau and Gramsci, and seek to apply it with coarse language, cultural war, and certain unbecoming weapons.
Anesthetized for a few days by the resentments of some and others, in a rare microclimate of magical truces, Robert Francis Prevost nevertheless unveiled a series of concepts drawn from the social doctrine of the Church that clash more with the anarcho-capitalist model than with the “liberal welfare” and the Peronism of the “Catholic nation.” Libertarian ideas and Christian democracy are in fact at opposite poles, and one might think that Leo left standing, with his speeches and sermons, a possible program for the opposition, a ready-made suit that, however, does not fit anyone; the theater remained full, the audience seated and waiting, but with no credible actor capable of delivering the performance. And that happens because there is no true republican with enough chances and political weight, and because when Kirchnerism and its adherents tried to carry out that same project, they embezzled it with catastrophic ineptitude and evident venality. It was the statists who devastated the State. The Pope also referred to how corruption erodes citizens’ trust: the memory is still fresh, comrades. None of the old Peronist figures is therefore plausible to embody Prevost’s proposals, which not only embody honesty and mercy, but also a renewed orthodox and heterodox spirituality that lingers in the air and could be felt in the massive demonstrations of these days. By the way: one cannot say that His Holiness is precisely “leftist,” but rather a recognized centrist who avoids wielding the demagoguery of the word “people”—preferring to reference a civic and plural community that seeks the common good and places limits on the strongest—and defends a “capitalism with a human face” that protects the poor but continues to believe firmly in markets and institutions. His postulates stand out against the mileian economic Darwinism and its disdain for the “rules of the caste” and the victims of the model, whom he must now go to beg for votes and renewed trust. The liminal message of this Augustinian, who seeks not a contest but a communion, mysteriously connects with other happenings across the American continent. They’re novel and overturn the false idea that The New Right dominates the scene in an irreducible way, and that today one can only practice politics from hatred and radicalization.
The beating that Democrats delivered to Trumpism did not represent a leftist victory, but a triumph of centrist liberals over right-wing populists. The center defeated the extreme not only in the planet’s most influential democracy, but in other countries where, at times, the ballot came in decisive alliance with “progressivism,” as in Brazil. We are accustomed to drawing grand definitive conclusions about trends that are imagined to exist on volatile beachsand, and societies stubbornly contradict them with their shifting, surprising, and sometimes spasmodic voting, and with their scant patience for incumbents—an essential factor that should worry both sides of the spectrum—no one has anything bought and no one should fall into the easy temptation of “going all in”—but especially La Libertad Avanza, which has committed grave errors, such as irresponsibly handing foreign policy to a faction: its messiah did not preserve the prudent diplomatic relations that endure beyond electoral junctures; he got involved in internal frictions of other nations, offended the diverse, and lately bet on a loser. The result of that clumsiness is self-imposed isolation, a matter with an uncertain end, at a delicate economic moment where inflation remains stubborn and recession consolidates, and markets punish Argentina with country risk and raise serious questions about funding for the coming year. Doubt and fear are not trivial: the lender of last resort is wounded and under parliamentary investigation, the promised bazooka lacks sufficient charge, investment and consumption do not revive, and it becomes evident that the stabilization plan’s design does not quite stabilize. Alfonso Prat-Gay, commenting on Leo’s visit, dropped a substantive remark: “An economic program cannot claim that the destruction of half of industry is mere collateral damage.” Both the collapse of Trump and Bolsonaro and Prevost’s preaching, with its prudence and its sentiments, hint at the cracks in a bubble of sense and the provisional autumn of an “undisputed” narrative. Without roars or scratches or blemishes, the Vatican lion contradicted the local lion on key matters: “The economy must serve the person, and not the other way around,” said the pontiff, and then questioned unemployment and a state that abdicates its duty to advocate for access to work. The Mole that comes to destroy the State from within may have tasted his own saliva; likewise when he heard papal diatribes against entrepreneurs who dehumanize themselves in the excessive pursuit of profit, technoligarchs who concentrate power and “seek to have algorithms replace human discernment,” and political leaders who overlook social justice and exclusion. A separate chapter is formed by three very sensitive issues that the Government did not manage to remove from its heated agenda: people with disabilities, universities, and education in general. The chainsaw insisted on mercilessly mutilating those funds, and replying with sarcasm or cruel indifference to the claims and criticisms raised. The operation launched after Prevost’s departure consisted of feigning forgetfulness and pretending not to be addressed: nothing happened here. But a great deal happened, and not only politically. The writer—trained as a Salesian and later resigned to agnosticism—confesses that the moving spectacle of popular affection touched a bit his sleepy faith. Many people who had long left churches said something similar; as did the weariness of living in an eternal trench. Will it be a temporary feeling, or a new spirit of the times?
—————————